In looking at your car and seeing you're 15, I think you have some bigger fish to fry and let's see if we can help you make the dash look better without dropping that kind of coin.
Here's my best "bucks down" approach to that dash.
I would remove the bezel and polish the plastic. I suggest Meguiars #10 plastic polish. If it doesn't clean up, you may have to get serious and wet sand with some 2000 grit paper first. Get that looking nice first. Removing the scratches is the most important thing you can do to make the cluster look nice... and the one that a lot of people skip. There's probably some you tube videos on the process.
For the bezel, I'd remove what's left of the "chrome" with some Easy-off oven cleaner. Try a spot on the back first, but I'm pretty sure that it won't attack the plastic. It will take off the chrome and old paint though.
I've read that the Duplicolor chrome paint is about the best rattle can "chrome". Paint the bezel black first (again, test the paint on the back first) and then very light coats of the chrome.
This will look decent and if you do a good job, no one will notice. Most times, people just spray on chrome paint real thick or don't bother with the black first. Then, it does look like crap, as I said above.